The birth of a child should be a moment of joy, not one overshadowed by unexpected injuries. Clavicle fractures are the most common birth injury, occurring in 0.5% to 4% of all newborn deliveries —yet despite their frequency, these injuries can still result from lapses in medical care that constitute negligence. Even more concerning, one in every 11 newborns who experiences a clavicle fracture during birth will also suffer damage to their brachial plexus, potentially causing arm paralysis that may be temporary or permanent.
In New York, determining whether a newborn’s clavicle fracture constitutes medical negligence requires careful examination of the circumstances surrounding the birth. While research shows that the majority of clavicular fractures occur in normal newborns following normal labor and delivery, this doesn’t mean all such injuries are unavoidable. Medical negligence occurs when healthcare providers fail to meet the accepted standard of care, directly causing harm to a patient. In the case of a newborn clavicle fracture, this means assessing whether the injury could have been prevented through proper medical judgment, techniques, or protocols—particularly in high-risk situations involving shoulder dystocia, macrosomia, or prolonged labor.
Birth injury settlements in the United States average approximately $1 million, and New York has no cap on birth injury compensation claims—meaning families can recover the full extent of damages when negligence is proven. Understanding when a fracture crosses the line from a common birth complication to potential malpractice is essential for parents seeking accountability and appropriate compensation for their child’s care.
This article will help you recognize situations where a clavicle fracture may indicate medical negligence, outline the legal process in New York, and provide guidance on the steps to take if you suspect malpractice has occurred. With the right knowledge, you can protect your child’s rights and make informed decisions during this challenging time.
At The Pagan Law Firm, we help New York and New Jersey families navigate the difficult aftermath of a newborn’s birth injury. If you suspect your child’s clavicle fracture resulted from medical negligence, reach out today at 212-967-8202 to learn how we can guide you through your legal options.
👉Also Read: What Are the Top Early Signs of Erb’s Palsy and When to Consult a Birth Injury Attorney in New York
Understanding Newborn Clavicle Fractures
A clavicle fracture, commonly referred to as a broken collarbone, is one of the most frequent birth injuries. It occurs when the bone connecting the arm to the body breaks, often as a result of pressure exerted on the baby during delivery. Such injuries are more likely during complicated vaginal births, particularly when instruments are used or when conditions like shoulder dystocia are present.
Parents should be aware of the causes and warning signs of a clavicle fracture, as early detection and proper management significantly reduce the risk of long-term complications for the newborn.
Causes During Childbirth
Several factors during childbirth can lead to clavicle fractures in newborns, including:
- Difficult vaginal deliveries: Excessive pressure on the baby can sometimes cause the collarbone to break.
- Improper use of vacuum extractors: Incorrect technique can result in fractures or other injuries.
- Improper use of forceps: Misapplied forceps can cause significant trauma to both the mother and the baby.
A particularly critical factor is shoulder dystocia, which occurs when the baby’s shoulders become lodged behind the mother’s pelvic bone during delivery. This condition demands immediate medical intervention to prevent fractures and other serious injuries. Additionally, failing to recognize and promptly respond to fetal distress can increase the likelihood of severe birth injuries, including clavicle fractures.
Signs of a Clavicle Fracture in Newborns
Early recognition of a clavicle fracture is essential for timely medical care. Common signs include:
- Limited or restricted movement of the affected arm, with the newborn keeping it close to their body.
- Crying or discomfort when the injured arm is touched, signaling pain.
- The appearance of a hard lump over the shoulder as the fracture begins to heal, which may be the only visible indication for parents.
Being aware of these signs allows parents to seek prompt medical evaluation, ensuring proper diagnosis, treatment, and monitoring for potential complications.
👉Also Read: Is Pitocin Misuse Grounds for a Birth Injury Lawsuit in New York?
When Is It Medical Negligence?
Not every clavicle fracture at birth is the result of medical negligence. In New York, a birth injury may constitute negligence when a healthcare provider fails to meet the accepted standard of care and that failure directly causes harm to the newborn. Determining negligence requires a careful examination of the delivery circumstances and the actions—or inactions—of the medical team.
Key Indicators of Potential Negligence Include:
- Failure to properly manage shoulder dystocia: Shoulder dystocia is a high-risk complication that demands immediate and skilled intervention. Delays, incorrect maneuvers, or improper techniques during this critical moment can result in avoidable fractures.
- Misuse of delivery instruments: Improper use of forceps or vacuum extractors, such as applying excessive force or using the devices inappropriately, can directly injure the newborn.
- Inadequate monitoring of fetal distress: Failing to recognize signs of fetal distress or delaying necessary medical intervention may contribute to birth injuries, including clavicle fractures.
- Deviation from standard delivery protocols: When healthcare providers disregard established medical guidelines or protocols during delivery, resulting in preventable harm, negligence may be present.
In essence, medical negligence occurs when a fracture could have been reasonably prevented through appropriate medical judgment, careful technique, and timely response. For parents, understanding these scenarios is crucial—not only for seeking accountability but also for ensuring that the newborn receives necessary treatment and protection under New York law.
Determining Medical Negligence
Establishing medical negligence in cases of newborn clavicle fractures in New York requires a detailed, step-by-step evaluation of both the medical care provided and the resulting injury. It is not enough to show that the newborn was injured during birth; parents must demonstrate that the injury occurred because the healthcare provider deviated from the accepted standard of care.
Key Factors Considered in Determining Negligence:
- Standard of care: This refers to the level of skill and caution that a reasonably competent medical professional would exercise in similar circumstances. Medical reviewers typically assess the actions of the attending physician, obstetrician, or delivery team by comparing them to widely accepted medical protocols.
- Causation: It must be shown that the provider’s actions—or failure to act—directly caused the clavicle fracture. If the injury had occurred despite proper care, negligence may not be present.
- Documentation and medical records: Detailed delivery records, fetal monitoring reports, and hospital charts are critical for evaluating whether appropriate procedures were followed.
- Expert testimony: Medical experts in obstetrics and neonatology are often required to interpret complex medical situations, identify deviations from standard care, and link these deviations to the injury.
- Preventability: Evidence that the fracture could have been avoided through proper techniques, timely intervention, or adherence to protocols strengthens the case for negligence.
Understanding these factors is crucial for parents who suspect that a clavicle fracture resulted from substandard medical care. Consulting with a qualified New York medical malpractice attorney can help navigate the legal process, gather the necessary evidence, and determine whether pursuing a claim is warranted.
👉Also Read: Filing a Broken Bone Birth Injury Claim in New York: What You Need to Know
Importance of Early Diagnosis and Proper Management
Early diagnosis and appropriate management of clavicle fractures in newborns are crucial to prevent long-term complications. Prompt identification of the injury allows healthcare providers to intervene quickly, reducing the risk of lasting harm and ensuring the newborn receives the care necessary for a full recovery.
Proper management typically involves comprehensive physical examinations, routine follow-ups, and consultation with pediatric specialists who can monitor healing and implement individualized care strategies.
Potential Long-Term Effects
If left untreated or poorly managed, clavicle fractures can lead to several long-term issues. Nerve damage associated with the fracture may cause temporary or permanent arm immobility, making physical therapy essential to restore strength and movement.
In some cases, a clavicle fracture can result in noticeable physical abnormalities, such as uneven shoulder alignment, which may affect the child’s appearance. Delayed or inadequate treatment can also contribute to impaired limb function, chronic pain, or other complications, all of which can impact the child’s overall quality of life.
Steps for Proper Management
Effective management of newborn clavicle fractures includes several key steps:
- Conducting thorough physical examinations to detect fractures before hospital discharge.
- Scheduling routine follow-ups to monitor healing progress and address any emerging issues.
- Engaging pediatric specialists to provide tailored care strategies, ensuring the newborn receives optimal treatment.
By following these steps, healthcare providers can minimize long-term risks, support proper healing, and help the newborn achieve a full and healthy recovery.
What is the Legal Process for Filing a Birth Injury Claim in New York?
If a newborn clavicle fracture is suspected to result from medical negligence, parents may have grounds to pursue a birth injury claim in New York. Understanding the legal process is essential to protect the child’s rights and ensure proper compensation for medical care, ongoing treatment, and associated damages.
Initial Consultation with a New York Birth Injury Attorney
The first step is to consult with an experienced New York medical birth injury attorney. During this consultation, parents can review medical records, delivery notes, and diagnostic reports to determine whether the injury may have resulted from substandard care. Attorneys can also provide guidance on legal options and the potential strength of the case.
Investigation and Evidence Gathering
Once a claim is considered viable, the attorney will conduct a thorough investigation. This includes:
- Collecting and reviewing hospital and medical records
- Consulting with medical experts in obstetrics and neonatology to evaluate whether the standard of care was breached
- Identifying deviations from accepted medical protocols that may have caused the injury
Filing a Notice of Claim or Complaint
In New York, malpractice cases against private healthcare providers are typically initiated by filing a formal complaint in court. Claims against public hospitals or government entities require a prior notice of claim within a specific timeframe. The complaint outlines the alleged negligence, the injury sustained, and the damages sought.
Discovery and Expert Testimony
The discovery phase involves exchanging evidence between parties, including depositions of medical personnel and expert witnesses. Expert testimony is crucial in establishing that the clavicle fracture was preventable and directly resulted from medical negligence.
Negotiation and Settlement
Many birth injury claims are resolved through negotiation or mediation before going to trial. Skilled medical negligence lawyers can negotiate for compensation covering medical bills, physical therapy, ongoing care, pain and suffering, and other related damages.
Trial
If a fair settlement cannot be reached, the case proceeds to trial. During trial, the attorney presents evidence and expert testimony to demonstrate negligence and the impact of the injury on the newborn and family. The court then determines liability and appropriate damages.
Statute of Limitations
In New York, medical malpractice claims generally must be filed within two years and six months from the date of the injury. Special rules apply for minors, cases involving public hospitals, and delayed discovery of the injury, so timely consultation with an attorney is critical.
Navigating a birth injury claim can be complex, but with the right legal guidance, parents can pursue accountability and secure the resources needed to support their child’s health and recovery.
How We Support Families Through Birth Injury Claims
Experiencing a birth injury can be overwhelming for any family. At The Pagan Law Firm, we are committed to providing compassionate guidance and strong legal representation to parents navigating this difficult time. From the moment a birth injury is suspected, we work closely with families to ensure their child’s rights are protected and their needs are fully addressed.
Comprehensive Case Investigation
Our New York birth injury lawyers begin by thoroughly reviewing medical records, delivery notes, and postnatal care documentation. Working with experienced medical professionals, we evaluate whether the injury, such as a clavicle fracture, was preventable and if healthcare providers deviated from accepted standards of care.
Guidance Through the Legal Process
We guide families through every stage of the legal process, including filing claims, gathering evidence, and consulting medical experts. Our team ensures that parents understand their options and can make informed decisions while navigating complex New York and New Jersey medical malpractice laws.
Advocacy and Financial Recovery
We are dedicated to holding healthcare providers accountable and helping families secure financial compensation for medical expenses, therapy, and pain and suffering. By pursuing these claims, we make sure families have the resources necessary for their child’s recovery and well-being.
Compassionate Support for Families
Beyond legal representation, we provide emotional support and clear communication throughout the process. Families can rely on our dedicated team to prioritize the health and future of their child, making the journey through a birth injury claim as manageable as possible.
With our birth injuries lawyer by your side, you gain not only skilled legal advocacy but also a trusted partner committed to protecting your child’s rights and helping your family move forward with confidence.
👉Also Read: How a New York Birth Injury Lawyer Handles Fetal Distress Cases
Protect Your Child’s Rights – Contact The Pagan Law Firm Today
If your newborn has suffered a clavicle fracture that may have resulted from medical negligence, acting quickly is essential. At The Pagan Law Firm, we understand the physical, emotional, and financial challenges families face when a preventable birth injury occurs.
We are here to help you navigate the complex legal process, thoroughly investigate the circumstances surrounding your child’s birth, and hold the responsible healthcare providers accountable. Our experienced New York birth injury attorneys work with medical experts to assess whether proper care was provided and fight for compensation for medical expenses, ongoing therapy, and the pain and suffering your family has endured.
Time is critical. In New York, medical malpractice claims must be filed within a specific timeframe, and delays can limit your ability to seek justice. Contact us today at 212-967-8202 or complete our online form to schedule a free consultation. With The Pagan Law Firm by your side, you gain compassionate guidance, skilled legal advocacy, and a dedicated partner committed to protecting your child’s rights and securing the resources your family deserves.
Frequently Asked Questions
What compensation can you pursue for a broken collarbone in New York?
In New York, the amount you may recover for a broken collarbone depends on the circumstances surrounding the injury. Factors such as the severity of the fracture, medical expenses, rehabilitation costs, lost income, pain and suffering, and any long-term or permanent impairment all influence the potential settlement or award. If the injury resulted from medical negligence, additional damages, such as emotional distress or future medical care, may also be considered.
Because each case is unique, consulting a New York attorney experienced in personal injury or medical negligence can help you understand the value of your claim and ensure your child’s or your own rights are fully protected.
What is the statute of limitations on birth injury in NY?
In New York, the statute of limitations for filing a birth injury claim generally follows the rules for medical malpractice cases. A birth injury lawsuit must typically be filed within two years and six months from the date of the injury. However, there are important exceptions:
- If the child dies as a result of the injury, a wrongful death claim must usually be filed within two years of the date of death.
- If the injured child is a minor, the statute of limitations may be extended. Claims must generally be filed within two years and six months from the date the injury was discovered, but in most cases, an action can be brought up until the child’s eighth birthday.
- Claims against public hospitals or government health care facilities often have shorter filing deadlines, requiring notice or filing within a specific period after the injury occurs.
Because these rules are complex and strict, consulting a New York medical malpractice lawyer promptly is essential to ensure your claim is filed on time and your child’s rights are protected.